What Happens When You Kill or Spare Jean Marc in Red Dead Redemption 2?

May 22, 2024

In Red Dead Redemption 2, what you do has an effect on the game. As players move through the game’s main tasks, they will have to make choices that will change the story.

In the “Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners” side task, you have to decide whether or not to kill Jean-Marc. Jean-Marc is the deputy to Henri Lemieux, who is the mayor of Saint-Denis. After completing the “Gilded Cage” quest, players will get a letter from the mayor telling them about this quest.

Players will meet Jean-Marc for the first time at the Mayor’s party, which Arthur also goes to. Shortly after the party, the Mayor will call Arthur, who will work with Marc to find Shiftacre, an art critic who has threatened to reveal that the Mayor’s paintings are fakes.

After talking to Shiftacre, it’s clear that Jean-Marc hates the Mayor’s shady and dishonest ways. In the end, Arthur will have to choose between Jean-Marc and the Mayor. Here’s what RDR2 players need to know about whether or not to kill Jean-Marc.

Many people think that Red Dead Redemption 2 is Rockstar’s best game. The game’s amazing open world and great story are two of its best parts. Many people also liked how much attention was paid to reality, even though some thought it went against the idea that video games should be fun.

Even the harshest reviewers of Red Dead Redemption 2 can’t argue that the game isn’t technically impressive and deserves all the praise it gets.

Who is Jean-Marc Mercier?

Even though Jean-Marc is a minor character, it doesn’t take long for him to show how honest he is. He works as an assistant for Henri Lemieux, who is the mayor of Saint-Denis and often uses corruption to make money for himself.

After going on a mission with him that the mayor himself gave, Jean-Marc is very unhappy with the work he has to do and makes it clear that he doesn’t want to work for such a dishonest person anymore.

What Happens When You Kill or Spare Jean Marc in Red Dead Redemption 2

He cares a lot about the city of Saint-Denis, and it’s clear that he doesn’t want shady people like Lemieux to run it. He is a good guy because he is honest, but in the Wild West, someone with such high ideals would die a cold, brutal death. Depending on the choices Arthur makes during this side quest, this man could end up in this situation.

Going Back to the Mayor’s House

After Shiftacre is forced to agree that the works are good, the Mayor will call Arthur again in a few days. This time, he wants Arthur to find a non-player character named Hector Fellowes and talk him into giving money to a public library.

Fellowes won’t give money voluntarily, so Arthur has to scare him to get the money. Arthur will then go back to the Mayor’s house to talk with him.

Lemieux is afraid that Jean-Marc will turn against him and show how crooked the city is. He also says that Jean-Marc might spread stories about what Arthur is doing wrong. Then, players will have to go to Jean Marc’s house in Saint-Denis, which is on Rue de Zacharie, just south of the A.

When the player sees Jean-Marc trying to open his door, a cutscene will begin. Arthur will kill him right away. Then, Arthur will have to sneak back to the Mayor’s house with Jean-Marc without being seen. Since it will be night, this step shouldn’t be too hard.

Should You Kill or Not Kill?

The Mayor will tell Arthur to bring Jean-Marc to the back of the property, which Arthur will do. When players get to the back courtyard of the house, they should drop Jean-Marc to start the last cutscene.

Jean-Marc will be tricked by Lemieux into thinking that his life will be saved, but the Mayor has much more evil plans. Jean-Marc doesn’t help his case when he tells the Mayor right in front of him that he is crooked.

Lemieux will tell Arthur to kill Jean-Marc at the end of the story. Arthur will be unsure about whether or not to do what the Mayor says. While Jean-Marc is on his knees begging for forgiveness, players will have to decide if they want to kill him or let him live.

Few players know that Marston, not Arthur, can actually finish the quest. The last cutscene will have different words because Jean-Marc is threatening Arthur, not Marston. He’ll say that Jean is “talking trash about my friends.” This small element was a cool part of a game with a lot of different ways to talk.

What Happens if the Players Kill Jean-Marc?

The biggest thing you get for killing Jean-Marc is a 10% discount at all stores in Saint-Denis. The mayor will thank Arthur for getting rid of Marc by writing him a letter. But if Arthur chooses this choice, his honor will go down. The other thing that will happen because of the decision is that drilling will start on the Indian Reservation.

After killing Jean-Marc, players will have to throw him into a nearby pond at the north end of the land. Players can find a secret Easter egg if they go back to the same spot and fish near it again at a later time.

What Happens When You Kill or Spare Jean Marc in Red Dead Redemption 2

Once Arthur throws out the line, he will pull something in, but it won’t be a fish. Jean Marc’s arm will be hooked to the hook at the end of the line.

What Happens if Jean-Marc Is Saved?

If Arthur lets Jean-Marc go, he will tell everyone about the Mayor’s illegal activities. Players will also get honor points that are good. Arthur will find out that Jean-Marc is the new mayor of Saint-Denis after a few days have passed in the game. Lemieux will have to leave his job because of the serious accusations against him.

Even though the Mayor says Jean-Marc will point the finger at Arthur, the right thing to do is to let the man go free. Still, it’s hard to pass up the 10% off and the amazing Easter egg.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is great because there is no one right way to play it. Players will enjoy doing the side quest, which is one of the most interesting in the game, no matter which choice they make.

Which Option Should They Choose?

At the end of the day, what players do in this story depends entirely on the type of game they want. In Red Dead Redemption 2, both low Honor and high Honor playthroughs are fun, with Arthur either giving in to his fears or being the bigger man when the situation calls for it.

At first, look, choosing to kill a character during a side mission might not seem like a big deal, but it helps the player’s story in a big way.

It is ethically right to save Jean-Marc, which leads to the Mayor’s corruption being exposed and Arthur getting Honor. It’s the right choice in the game, but if players want to stay on good terms with the mayor, they can still kill Jean-Marc instead.

This is a dishonorable action, but players get a 10% discount at all shops in Saint-Denis. However, if players have been careful with their money and built up a small fortune while exploring the world of Red Dead Redemption 2, this isn’t a huge benefit.

ncG1vNJzZmismJrAqa3Hmplnm5%2BifKO4zqBma2hiaHxxhI5qb2ivmJbBbrTAqaeepqNixKmxzWawqK1doLatuIyoqWaroJa%2FpnnJnpinZZ2Wv6R5yKdkq52UYrGmrcNmqZ6claK9tbXOp2RrZw%3D%3D